Last Updated on 8 December 2024 by Brisbane Livewell Clinic
There are some common misconceptions about consuming soy foods as part of a healthy diet, as soy has been controversial for many years. While some experts promote soy as a healthy food, others warn against its potential pitfalls. To better understand soy, it’s essential to consider some of the different aspects that make this food a hot topic.
Some groups of people will benefit more from soy’s health giving effects, including vegans and vegetarians, chronic disease sufferers and menopausal women. Conversely, anyone with a soy allergy or hypothyroidism will need to adjust their soy intake accordingly – ranging from total avoidance to moderation of quality soy products.
Who Benefits Most from Soy Consumption
- Vegans and Vegetarians: Soy is a complete protein that contains all the essential amino acids our bodies need to build and repair tissues. This is a great alternative to animal protein sources for those with a predominantly plant-based diet. Soybeans are noted for the total protein content and the quality of soy protein, which is higher than other plant proteins and, more significantly, similar to animal protein. (1)
- Chronic disease sufferers: Soy has been found to have several health benefits, including reducing the risk of reducing chronic diseases such as obesity, cardiovascular disease, insulin-resistance/type II diabetes, certain types of cancers, and immune disorders. (2) As part of a balanced diet, many individuals can benefit from adding a plant based protein like soy to their diet.
- Menopausal Women: Soy foods have the potential to address several conditions associated with the menopausal transition. (3) Provided they contain sufficient amounts of the predominant soybean isoflavone genistein, soybean isoflavones modestly alleviate hot flashes in menopausal women. (3)(4)
Who Should Consider Avoiding Soy or Minimising Intake
- Soy Allergy: This allergy commonly affects approximately 0.4% of children. Testing the theory of the common perception that a soy allergy is outgrown, one study showed that approximately 50% of children with soy allergy outgrew their allergy by age seven years of age. (5) Seeking advice when there is a history of food allergy is always advisable.
- Hypothyroid patients: Hypothyroid adults need not avoid it completely, but since soy foods can inhibit the absorption of iodine, it’s important for soy food consumers to make sure their intake of iodine is adequate. (6) Soy protein may also increase the amount of the thyroid medication needed, as it may interfere with the absorption of the medication. (1) Since thyroid medication is usually taken on waking in the morning, consuming quality soy products in moderation at the evening meal is the best way to reduce this potential effect.
Smart Soy Choices
The golden rule prioritises consuming fermented and wholefood varieties of soy such as tofu, tempeh, miso, edamame and natto. Fermentation has been used as a potent way of improving the properties of soybean and their components. (7) Remember that not all soy products are created equal. Many soy based products like soy yoghurt, mock meats and soybean oils are heavily processed and generally lack the nutrition that makes soy so special.
Finally, seeking personalised dietary advice about soy can help inform your dietary choices. Feeling the benefits from food choices like soy and understanding their potent effects is another testament to the power of plants, with soy appearing to be a in a league of its own.
These Wellness Blogs may also interest you. Click HERE or HERE or HERE
Check out THIS recipe.
Our Amazing Naturopaths at Brisbane Livewell Clinic
Shella Hall (Sunshine Coast and online)
Amy Angus (Wavell Heights and online)
Jen Strachan (Cannon Hill and online)
Nicole Odlum (Wavell Heights and online)
Dominique Johanson (Wavell Heights and online)
Locations We Service – Naturopathy
Naturopath Caloundra
Naturopath Wavell Heights
Naturopath Cannon Hill
Naturopath Sunshine Coast
Naturopath Brisbane Northside
Naturopath Brisbane
Naturopaths Brisbane
Brisbane Naturopaths
Naturopathy Brisbane
Naturopaths Near Me
Best Naturopaths Near Me
Best Naturopath Near Me
Relevant Naturopath links
Why You May Wish to Consult a Naturopath
Gut Health
- Gut Health
- Solving Gut Issues by Treating SIBO
- SIBO Test Brisbane
- Daily Ritual Gut Health
- 6 Digestive Problems that Cause Weight Gain
- How Stool Testing Helps IBS Sufferers Part 1: Digestive Markers
- How Stool Testing Helps IBS Sufferers Part 2: Microbial Markers
- Gut Health with Parasite Cleanse
- Natural Parasite Cleanse Australia
- The Gut-Brain Connection to Mental Health
- The Gut-Brain Connection: How to Feed Your Brain
- Controlling Constipation and Bloating
- How Stool Testing Helps Find the Causes of IBS and Other Digestive Health Problems
- Gut Health Brisbane
- Gut Health Specialist Brisbane
Hormone Health and Thyroid Issues
- Hormonal Health and Thyroid Issues
- PCOS and the Insulin Connection
- Identifying Insulin Resistance
- Looking at Luteal Phase Deficiency
- Experiencing Painful Periods? Here’s What Might Be Causing It
- When You Suspect You Have Thyroid Issues
- Subclinical Hypothyroidism: When You Suspect You Have a Thyroid Issue
- Thyroid Disorders from a Naturopathic Aspect
- Thyroid Health for the Winter Months
- Thyroid Disease: A Brief Guide to Common Disorders
- Naturopathic Thyroid Specialist Near Me
- Hyperthyroidism
- Hypothyroidism and Hashimoto’s
- Thyroid
- Hyperthyroidism and Graves’ Disease
Detox and Cleansing
- Heavy Metal Toxicity: Strategies for Detoxing
- Detoxing Your Lifestyle, Not Just Your Body
- Heavy Metal Detox for Kids
- Naturopathic Detox Cleanse
- Naturopath Detox
- Do I Need a Heavy Metal Detox?
- Heavy Metal Detox Australia
Insomnia and Sleep Health
- Save Your Sleep with What You Eat
- Insomnia Linked to Mineral Deficiency
- Solving Insomnia: Naturopathy’s Five-Step Solution
- 5 Ways Insomnia Can Affect Your Life and What You Can Do About It
- Natural Treatment for Insomnia
- Naturopathic Remedies for Insomnia
Autoimmune Conditions
Mental Health
- The Gut-Brain Connection to Mental Health
- The Gut-Brain Connection: How to Feed Your Brain
- Treating Depression with Naturopathy: What You Should Consider
- A Naturopath’s Guide to Improving Mental Health
- Naturopathic Anxiety Medication
- Naturopath Anxiety
- Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD): How a Naturopath Helps
- Pyrrole Disorder
Women’s Health
- Women’s Health
- Hormonal Imbalance
- Naturopath Women’s Health
- Women’s Health Week: It’s All About Women’s Wellness and Wellbeing
- Treating Vaginal Thrush the Natural Way
- The Lowdown on Low Libido
- Regulating Menstrual Cycles with Chaste Tree
- Painful Periods and Naturopathy
- Preventing Post-Pill Acne
Fertility and Pregnancy
- Pregnancy
- Pre-Pregnancy Fertility Care with Naturopathic Nutrition
- Fertility Naturopath Brisbane
- Acupuncture and Naturopathy for Pre-Conception Care
- Pregnancy Care and Naturopathy
- Maximising Nutrition Before and During Pregnancy
- Getting Quality Sleep in the 3rd Trimester of Pregnancy
- Pregnancy Wellbeing and Naturopathy are Great Partners
- Naturopathy for the Management of Constipation During Pregnancy
- Prenatal Naturopath
- Postpartum Depression and Anxiety
- Keeping Calm About Colic
Men’s Health
- Men’s Health
- The Sperm Health Decline
- Better Prostate Health with Natural Medicine
- Naturopathy and Men’s Health
- Support Your Thyroid Health Naturally
DNA Testing
- DNA Testing & Personalised Medicine
- DNA Testing Brisbane
- DNA Testing Brisbane, Australia
- Methylation Test Near Me
- Testing Functional Medicine
- Genetic Methylation Test Brisbane
- DUTCH Test Providers Near Me
Leaky Gut Syndrome
Food Intolerances and Allergies
- 7 Useful Strategies for Overcoming Food Intolerance
- Hayfever and the Gastrointestinal Immune System
- Food Intolerance, Hypersensitivity, and Allergies Explained
- Everything You Need to Know About Food Intolerance
- Food Allergy Testing Near Me
- Food Intolerance Testing Brisbane
- Food Allergy Testing
- Food Intolerance Testing
- Food Intolerance Testing Package
Weight Loss
- Can Irritable Bowel Syndrome Cause Weight Gain? (IBS)
- Naturopathy for Weight Loss
- Natural Weight Loss for Summer
- A Naturopathic Approach to Achieving an Ideal and Healthy Weight
- Intermittent Fasting: A Naturopath’s Guide to Success
- Weight Loss Naturopath
- Kick-Start Weight Loss: 5 Science-Backed Tips
- Combining Therapies for a Healthy Weight
- Naturopath’s Weight Loss Programme
Nutrition and Mineral Deficiencies
- Nutrition and Naturopathy: Healthy Diet
- Optimising Nutrition for Skin Health
- The Seriousness of Sugar
- The Importance of Mindfulness and Meditation in Natural Medicine
- Nutrition Deficiency: Visible Body Look Signs
- Helping Cardiovascular Disease in Women
- Sports Nutrition and Your Ideal Protein Requirements
- Creating a Healthy Diet for Good Health and Wellbeing
- Maximising Nutrition Before and During Pregnancy
- Nutrition and Naturopathy: Healthy Diet
- Combining Therapies for a Healthy Weight
- Intermittent Fasting: A Naturopath’s Guide to Success
- Iron Deficiency and Anaemia: When Things Go from Bad to Worse
- Naturopathic Medicine: What You Need to Know
- National Herbal Medicine Week
- The Role of Nutrition and Naturopathy in Wellbeing